Published on 01/29/2024
The Short Winter
By Carsten Haese, Nathan Long, and Justin Hovdenes
This Article from: Nathan Long
Cranial Translation
Deutsch
Français
I can't really ski if that's all the snow
you're giving me.
you're giving me.
But if you have questions about any Magic rules interaction, you can send them in to us, and we'll send you an answer back. We may even use your question in a future article. If you have a shorter question, you can find us at @CranialTweet, but if you have a longer question, you can e-mail us at moko@cranialinsertion.com .
Q: Does Agatha of the Vile Cauldron reduce the cost of her own activated ability?
A: Yes she does! Agatha doesn't exclude herself in the activated ability's discount - it would say "Activated abilities of other creatures you control..." for that to be true. So by default, Agatha's activated ability will cost
to activate since her power is 1, and if you get her up to a power of 4 or greater, then her ability will only cost to activate.Q: I control Hylda of the Icy Crown and currently control three artifacts. If I cast Dispatch targeting an opponent's untapped creature, will I get a Hylda trigger?
A: You will! Dispatch will always tap the targeted creature. The metalcraft bonus is an extra effect that happens if you control three or more artifacts when it resolves. It's not replacing tapping the creature with exiling it instead, you just do both. Normally, tapping the creature before it's exiled won't do anything, but Hylda will see that a spell you controlled tapped an untapped creature an opponent controls, and Hylda will trigger.
Q: I control a Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel with four chorus counters on it. I attack with it, it deals combat damage to the opponent, and I discard Nexus of Fate to Malcolm's trigger. Can I cast the Nexus of Fate?
A: No, you won't be able to cast it. Nexus of Fate has a replacement effect, so it never ends up in the graveyard - it's shuffled into the library instead of going to the graveyard. Since Nexus of Fate didn't end up in a public zone, we can't perform the second part of Malcolm's effect and you won't be able to cast the discarded Nexus of Fate.
Q: I cast Nissa, Ascended Animist and she enters the battlefield with five loyalty counters. If I activate the +1 ability to make a token, is the token a 5/5 or a 6/6?
A: You create a 6/6 token. The ability will look at the amount of loyalty Nissa has when the activated ability resolves, not how many counters she had before you activated the ability. When the +1 ability resolves, Nissa has six loyalty counters on her, so her ability will make a 6/6 token.
Q: If I activate Deathrite Shaman's second ability, causing my opponent to lose 2 life, then cast Scab-Clan Mauler, will my Mauler enter with two +1/+1 counters from bloodthirst?
A: No it will not. Bloodthirst checks to see if an opponent has been dealt damage this turn. But Deathrite Shaman doesn't deal damage to the opponent - it causes your opponents to lose life. Losing life doesn't count as dealing damage, so the Shaman's activated ability won't turn on your bloodthirst creature.
Q: I have a Swarm Shambler and an Alpine Grizzly in play. My opponent casts Lightning Strike targeting my Alpine Grizzly. If I respond by casting Snakeskin Veil on my Alpine Grizzly, will my Swarm Shambler also trigger and give me a token?
A: No, it won't trigger. For Swarm Shambler to trigger, your Grizzly has to have a +1/+1 counter on it when Lightning Strike is cast. It won't retroactively trigger if the Grizzly gains a +1/+1 counter after being targeted by the Strike. While your Grizzly will survive since it has hexproof, it didn't have a +1/+1 counter on it when the Strike was cast, and Swarm Shambler will not trigger.
Q: My opponent casts Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger and targets two of my permanents with its cast trigger. In response, I cast Tishana's Tidebinder and counter Ulamog's cast trigger. Does that cause the Ulamog spell to lose all abilities, making it just a 10/10 without indestructible or the attack trigger once it's on the battlefield?
A: No it does not. Tishana only removes the abilities if the source of the ability was an artifact, creature, or planeswalker on the battlefield, not if the source of the ability is a spell on the stack (see 109.2 of the Magic Comprehensive Rules). If you're countering Ulamog's cast trigger, Ulamog is a "creature spell" at that point, not a "creature", so countering the cast trigger won't cause Ulamog to lose its abilities. If you wanted Ulamog to lose its abilities, you'd have to wait for Ulamog to attack, then use the Tidebinder to counter Ulamog's attack trigger.
Any snow we do get will start melting
shortly afterwards.
shortly afterwards.
Q: I control a 0/0 Germ token equipped with Kaldra Compleat. I attack with it, and my opponent blocks with a creature. After damage is dealt, with the combat damage trigger from Kaldra Compleat on the stack, my opponent counters the trigger with Tishana's Tidebinder. What happens to my Germ token?
A: Your token ends up as a 5/5 with no other abilities. Kaldra Compleat gives the combat damage trigger to the creature, so the creature is the source of that trigger, not the Equipment. Your opponent is free to counter the trigger with the Tidebinder, but that means that the Germ token is losing its abilities, not the Equipment. The effect from the Tidebinder does have a later timestamp than the Equipment, so the Germ token loses all of the static and triggered abilities given to it by the Equipment. But the Germ token keeps +5/+5 from Kaldra Compleat, so the Germ token ends up as a 5/5 with no other abilities from the Equipment.
You can technically reset the timestamp of Kaldra Compleat if you move the Equipment to another creature and then back to the Germ token, since reattaching it will update the timestamp for the Equipment. But you'll need a toughness booster for the Germ token to keep it alive when you move Kaldra Compleat to another creature, or else the token become a 0/0 and dies.
Q: My opponent just cast Warp World, and one of the permanents I put onto the battlefield is Rampaging Ferocidon. Will the Ferocidon trigger for any of the other creatures that are put onto the battlefield with Warp World?
A: Yep, it will. The Ferocidon will see other creatures that enter the battlefield at the same time as the Ferocidon, and it will trigger for all of them. This could result in a lot of damage for some or all players.
Q: My opponent and I are both at 1 life. I have an untapped Pili-Pala in play with a bunch of Forests, while my opponent controls a Norn's Annex. Can I declare an attack with Pili-Pala and also activate its ability to produce one white mana so I can pay the Annex tax?
A: Yeah, that actually works. When we're declaring attackers, we tap the creatures we're attacking with first, then we worry about paying additional costs to enable the attack, like the Annex. Since Pili-Pala will become tapped first, we can activate Pili-Pala's untap ability, produce one white mana, and then use that mana to pay to allow for Pili-Pala to attack (and Pili-Pala will still be attacking, even though it's now untapped).
Q: Can I use Mystic Forge to cast a face down creature from the top of my library?
A: Yes you can. A face down creature spell is colorless, and Mystic Forge lets you cast colorless spells from the top of your library. Even though the Firecat is red when it's in your library, when you decide to cast it face down, it's colorless, and can be cast via the Forge's ability.
Q: Will Grafdigger's Cage stop me from casting the copy made by Arcane Proxy?
A: It will not. Arcane Proxy doesn't cast the copy from the graveyard - you exile the card first, then make a copy of it. Since Arcane Proxy exiles the card before making the copy, the copy is created and cast from exile. Grafdigger's Cage prevents players from casting spells from the graveyard and library, but not from exile, so you'll be able to cast the copy made by Arcane Proxy.
Q: My opponent has my Leonin Arbiter exiled to their Leyline Binding. If I channel Boseiju, Who Endures targeting my opponent's Leyline Binding, will they be able to search for a land?
A: They won't. When Boseiju's ability resolves, the first thing we do is destroy the Binding. Since the Binding left the battlefield, the exiled Arbiter immediately returns to the battlefield. Then your opponent would search their library for a land, but because you now have Leonin Arbiter in play, they won't be able to search. They don't even get the chance to pay
to ignore the Arbiter's effect, since that's only an action they can take when they have priority, and they don't have priority in the middle of Boseiju's ability resolving. Not only did your opponent lose their Binding, they won't be able to search for a land with the second part of Boseiju's effect.I definitely don't miss having snowstorms like this.
Q: How does Twinning Staff work with Spellweaver Helix? Will I be able to cast two copies of the other exiled card when the Helix's trigger resolves?
A: No, there's no interaction here. The Staff's static ability only applies if you're copying a spell on the stack. The Helix doesn't copy a spell on the stack - you copy the card in exile, then you can cast the copy. Since you're not copying a spell on the stack, Twinning Staff won't care about that copy and won't give you two copies of the exiled card to cast.
Q: My commander Lazav, Dimir Mastermind is in play. My opponent casts their commander, but I counter it with a Counterspell. Assuming my opponent wants to move their commander to the command zone, can my Lazav still copy it?
A: Yep, Lazav can still copy your commander. Your opponent's commander will briefly go to the graveyard before they move it to the command zone when state-based actions are checked. Since it did briefly go to the graveyard, your Lazav will trigger and Lazav will be able to copy your opponent's commander (even if it's not in the graveyard anymore).
Q: I have a Carrion Feeder in play. Can I cast Rot Hulk, then sacrifice the Hulk to the Feeder's ability before its enter-the-battlefield trigger goes on the stack and target the Hulk itself with its enter-the-battlefield trigger?
A: You cannot. After the Hulk has resolved, before you get a chance to do anything else, you have to put the Hulk's trigger on the stack. Since the trigger targets, you have to choose targets for the ability at that point. But since the Hulk is still on the battlefield when you're choosing targets, it's not a legal target for its trigger, and you won't be able to target the Hulk with its own trigger.
Q: I have no creatures in play, and my opponent just activated the last ability of Shaman of Forgotten Ways. Can I save myself by casting Teferi's Protection?
A: Yep, you can save yourself. Teferi's Protection does a lot of things to protect you and your permanents, and one of those thing is making it so your life total can't change. When the ability of the Shaman resolves, it would try to make your life total 0 (since you control no creatures), but because of the Protection, your life total can't change and it will stay where it's at.
Q: My opponent controls a Myojin of Roaring Blades. If I cast Cursed Mirror and copy it, will my Mirror enter with an indestructible counter?
A: As long as you cast Cursed Mirror from your hand, yes. If you cast it from your hand, when you choose to copy the Myojin, since it's now entering as the Myojin, the Myojin's own replacement effect will apply and it will enter with an indestructible counter. You can then activate the Myojin's ability and deal 7 damage to up to three targets. But if you don't activate the ability, once the turn ends and it goes back to being a Cursed Mirror, it still has the indestructible counter on it, and Cursed Mirror will be indestructible.
Q: If I have two Extravagant Replications in play, can they target and copy each other?
A: Yep, you can do that. The Replication can't target itself with its own trigger, but it can still target another Replication. If you'd like, you can have the Replications target each other, and then you'll have four copies of the Replication in play.
Q: My opponent controls a Charismatic Conqueror. If I cast an Equipment like Diamond Pick-Axe, can I tap it to the Conqueror's trigger but also activate its equip ability afterwards?
A: Yep, you can do that. The Pick-Axe is an artifact, so the Pick-Axe entering untapped will cause the Conqueror to trigger. When the trigger resolves, you're free to tap the Pick-Axe to prevent your opponent from getting a token. But tapped Equipment still function fine, so even if the Pick-Axe is tapped, you'll still be able to activate the equip ability and attach it to a creature you control.
That's all we have for this week. See you again next week as we dive into Murders at Karlov Manor!
No comments yet.
